Lum-Tec Automatic vs Quartz vs Solar: Which Movement Is Right for You?

Lum-Tec currently offers three movement types in its in-stock lineup: automatic, quartz, and solar. The case styles vary, but the movement is often the decision that matters most. This guide explains how those three types differ and compares six in-stock models you can shop at CGA today.

The CGA Company is an authorized Lum-Tec dealer in Chenoa, IL. We sell new watches only, and shipping is free on watches to addresses in the United States. The specs and prices below come from our product pages and lum-tec.com. Our prices match lum-tec.com. Every model here is assembled, tested and tuned in Mentor, Ohio, and uses Lum-Tec's MDV lume.

If you are comparing movement types only inside the Combat B series, see Combat B quartz vs. automatic vs. chronograph. For the Solar Marine models as a group, see Solar Marine 5, 6, 7 and 8 compared.

Automatic vs quartz vs solar, in brief

Quartz. A battery-powered movement that you set and then leave alone. You do not wind it, and it keeps running whether or not you wear it every day. In the current in-stock lineup, the Combat B72 and Combat B73 use a Swiss Ronda 515, and the RPM 3 uses a Japanese Miyota OS20 quartz chronograph. Lum-Tec provides free lifetime battery replacement on these quartz models, under Lum-Tec's terms.

Solar. A solar-quartz movement that charges from light, so there are no routine battery changes. Lum-Tec's current Solar Marine models use a Japanese VS42A. Lum-Tec and our product pages list about six months of running time on a full charge, and about one minute of sunlight for a day of running.

Automatic. A mechanical movement that winds as you wear it. Several of the automatics here have a sapphire display caseback so you can see the movement. The Combat B69's Miyota 9015 can also be wound by hand and hacks so you can set it to the second. Current in-stock automatics use Japanese Miyota calibers, including the 9015, 9039, and 9075. Lum-Tec regulates or adjusts these movements in six positions after assembly; wording varies by model and is listed in the table below.

Side-by-side comparison

Model Type Case Movement Water resistance Price
RPM 3 Quartz chronograph 43 mm; 11.3 mm thick (12.3 mm overall); 41 mm lug to lug; 20 mm lugs; 316L steel with gunmetal PVD Japanese Miyota OS20 quartz chronograph 50 meters $495
Combat B72 Quartz 43 mm; 13.6 mm thick; 51.5 mm lug to lug; 22 mm lugs; forged 316L steel with gunmetal PVD Swiss Ronda 515 quartz 200 meters $595
Solar Marine 5 Solar 39 mm; 10.7 mm thick; 43.5 mm lug to lug; 20 mm lugs; forged 316L steel, brushed and polished Japanese VS42A solar quartz; about six months of running time on a full charge 300 meters $545
Solar Marine 6 Solar 39 mm; 10.7 mm thick; 43.5 mm lug to lug; 20 mm lugs; forged 316L steel with bead-blasted black PVD Japanese VS42A solar quartz; about six months of running time on a full charge 300 meters $595
Eclipse E1 Automatic 42 mm; 9.1 mm thick; 47 mm lug to lug; forged 316L steel with an integrated bracelet Japanese Miyota 9039 automatic; adjusted in six positions after assembly 100 meters $795
Combat B69 Automatic 43 mm; 13.6 mm thick; 51.5 mm lug to lug; 22 mm lugs; forged 316L steel with gunmetal PVD Japanese Miyota 9015 automatic, 28,800 BPH, hand winding and hacking seconds; regulated in-house in six positions 200 meters $1,095

Other in-stock options in these same movement groups include the Combat B73 quartz ($545), the Combat Field X4 titanium automatic ($995), and the M94 Bronze No-Date GMT automatic ($1,175). Solar Marine 7 ($545) and Solar Marine 8 ($595) use the same VS42A solar movement as the Solar Marine 5 and 6; see the Solar Marine comparison for the differences among those four.

Which movement fits how you wear a watch

Choose quartz if you want a watch you can set and then forget, or if you rotate several watches and do not want to wind one that has sat for a few days. The Combat B72 ($595) is the quartz pick if you want a 43 mm gunmetal Combat B field watch with 200 meters of water resistance and an inverse-lume dial. The RPM 3 ($495) is the quartz pick if you want a chronograph in a more compact 41 mm lug-to-lug case; note that it is rated to 50 meters, the lowest water resistance in this group.

Choose solar if you want a watch that charges from light and has no routine battery changes, especially if you also want the highest water resistance in the current lineup. The Solar Marine 5 ($545) is the 39 mm steel dive watch with a brushed and polished finish and a 300-meter rating. The Solar Marine 6 ($595) is the same size and movement in a bead-blasted black PVD case.

Choose automatic if you want a mechanical movement and, on most of these models, a view of it through a sapphire display caseback. The Eclipse E1 ($795) is the automatic pick if you want a thinner 42 mm watch (9.1 mm thick) with an integrated bracelet and a 100-meter rating. The Combat B69 ($1,095) is the automatic version of the 43 mm gunmetal Combat B case, with a Miyota 9015 that can be wound by hand and hacks so you can set it to the second, and a 200-meter rating. If you want a titanium field automatic or a bronze GMT, look at the Combat Field X4 and the M94 Bronze No-Date GMT.

FAQ

What is the difference between a Lum-Tec automatic, quartz, and solar watch?

Quartz models run on a battery and do not need winding. Solar models use a solar-quartz movement that charges from light, with about six months of running time on a full charge and no routine battery changes. Automatic models are mechanical and wind as you wear them. All three types in this guide are assembled, tested and tuned in Mentor, Ohio, and use Lum-Tec's MDV lume.

Do CGA prices match lum-tec.com?

Yes. The prices in this guide match the current listings on lum-tec.com and on our product pages.

Is The CGA Company an authorized Lum-Tec dealer?

Yes. We are an authorized Lum-Tec dealer in Chenoa, IL. We sell new watches only, and we ship to addresses in the United States only.

Do quartz and solar Lum-Tec watches need battery changes?

Quartz models such as the Combat B72 and the RPM 3 use a battery. Lum-Tec provides free lifetime battery replacement on those models, under Lum-Tec's terms. Solar Marine models do not need routine battery changes; Lum-Tec and our product pages list about six months of running time on a full charge.

Which of these has the highest water resistance?

The Solar Marine 5 and Solar Marine 6 are rated to 300 meters. The Combat B72 and Combat B69 are rated to 200 meters. The Eclipse E1 is rated to 100 meters. The RPM 3 is rated to 50 meters.

Do you offer free shipping?

Yes. Shipping is free on watches to US addresses.

Shop these watches

Browse all current models in our Lum-Tec collection, or go directly to the RPM 3, Combat B72, Solar Marine 5, Solar Marine 6, Eclipse E1, or Combat B69. For a first-watch overview, start with How to Choose Your First Lum-Tec Watch. Learn more about buying from us on our authorized Lum-Tec dealer page.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.